•  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  • Untitled Document
    Untitled Document

    New York high court upholds local bans on hydraulic fracturing

    Heather Palmer, Michael Weller, Bracewell & Giuliani LLP

    On June 30, 2014, the New York State Court of Appeals, the highest court in the state, held that municipalities can effectively “zone out” oil and gas operations by passing zoning ordinances that ban oil and gas production activities, including hydraulic fracturing, within municipal boundaries.  The court rejected claims that the state’s Oil Gas and Solution Mining Law (OGSML) preempts efforts on behalf of local authorities to ban hydraulic fracturing operations.

    In 2011, the Town of Dryden, New York banned hydraulic fracturing by passing a zoning ordinance that prohibited “all activities related to the exploration for, and the production or storage of, natural gas and petroleum.” Norse Energy challenged the ordinance, arguing that the Town of Dryden lacked authority to prohibit natural gas exploration and extraction activities because the OGSML preempts local zoning laws that curtail energy production.  The lower court concluded there was no evidence of express or implied preemption in the OGSML.   

    In May 2013, an appellate panel of the New York Supreme Court affirmed the decision of the lower court, holding that local municipalities have the power to enact zoning ordinances that ban “all activities related to the exploration for, and the production or storage of, natural gas and petroleum within its borders.”

    The Dryden case was heard with a similar case between the Town of Middlefield, New York and Cooperstown Holstein Corporation (“CHC”).  In 2011, the Town of Middlefield adopted a zoning ordinance prohibiting “oil, gas and solution mining and drilling” within its boundaries.  CHC brought an action to set aside the zoning law, claiming that it was preempted by the OGSML.  As in the Town of Dryden case, both the lower court and the appellate court upheld the legality of the zoning law.

    In its June 30th decision, the New York State Court of Appeals considered the power ceded to municipalities in New York under their home rule authority and whether the text of the OGSML includes any provisions that preempt zoning ordinances that ban oil and gas activities in the state.

    The court distinguished between local laws that purport to regulate the actual operations of oil and gas activities (which are preempted by the OGSML) and zoning ordinances that restrict or prohibit certain land uses within town boundaries (which are not).  In the court’s view, the zoning laws at issue were directed at regulating land use generally and did not attempt to govern the details, procedures or operations of the oil and gas industry.

    While the court recognized that the local bans would undeniably have an impact on oil and gas businesses and individual landowners in Dryden and Middlefield, the court found that the plain language of the OGSML, the statutory scheme, and the legislative history did not support preemption.  The court affirmed the decisions of the appellate courts.

    The dissent points out that the “zoning ordinances of Dryden and Middlefield do more than just regulate land use, they regulate oil, gas and solution mining industries under the pretext of zoning.”  By creating a blanket ban on oil and gas activities within their boundaries, the dissent noted that these towns were going above and beyond zoning and, instead, regulating those industries.

    The court’s decision in the Dryden and Middlefield cases will have a significant impact on future development of the New York Marcellus Shale.  Although the State of New York placed a moratorium on hydraulic fracturing in July 2008, any future attempts to lift the moratorium could prove irrelevant in light of this ruling.  With as many as 170 municipalities enacting bans or moratoriums on hydHeather Palmerraulic fracturing and more expected to follow, absent a change in the OGSML, future oil and gas development in the state is at risk.

    About the author
    As a partner in the environmental strategies group, Heather Corken Palmer helps energy, petrochemical and pipeline companies and private equity firms that are seeking guidance on environmental compliance and the allocation of environmental liabilities in mergers and acquisitions. Her areas of focus include onshore and offshore oil and gas regulation; solid and hazardous waste; oil and gas waste; environmental remediation; water quality; water rights; wetlands; endangered species; Superfund litigation; and compliance with the National Environmental Policy Act. She plays a major role in advising clients on the environmental issues surrounding shale play development, hydraulic fracturing and the permitting, construction and operation of liquefied natural gas (LNG) import/export facilities in the US.

    Michael Weller
    Michael Weller is an attorney in the environmental strategies group at Bracewell & Giuliani. He advises clients in the energy sector in the context of government investigations and enforcement actions, regulatory compliance and advocacy, litigation, permitting and in quantifying and allocating liabilities during business transactions. 

    Most Popular

    Related Articles

    Douglas-Westwood comments on Brazil’s upstream challenges

    07/06/2015 In the July 6 edition of its DW Monday report, Douglas-Westwood commented that Brazil is facing deep upstream challenges. While the adoption and deployment of deepwater technology has enabled Petro...

    Comstock to divest certain East Texas assets

    07/02/2015 Comstock Resources Inc. has entered into a definitive purchase and sale agreement with a private company to sell Comstock's oil and gas properties in and around Burleson County, Texas, for a sale p...

    Glori Energy elects Puckett as new board chairman

    07/01/2015 Glori Energy Inc. has elected Mark Puckett as the company’s new chairman of the board. Puckett succeeds John U. Clarke, who resigned June 29 from Glori's board after four years of service to focus ...

    EGAS to conduct largest Mediterranean seismic exploration project

    06/26/2015

    Egyptian Natural Gas Holding Co. (EGAS) is set to carry out the largest seismic oil and gas exploration project in the Mediterranean, according to Reuters.

    RRC: Texas monthly oil and gas statistics

    06/25/2015

    The Railroad Commission of Texas has released monthy statistics for oil and gas activity in Texas.  

    Amec Foster Wheeler appoints new president of upstream business development

    06/25/2015

    Amec Foster Wheeler has appointed George Hernandez as president of upstream business development. He will be based in the company’s Houston office. 

     

    More Oil & Gas Financial Articles

    Douglas-Westwood comments on Brazil’s upstream challenges

    Mon, Jul 6, 2015

    In the July 6 edition of its DW Monday report, Douglas-Westwood commented that Brazil is facing deep upstream challenges. While the adoption and deployment of deepwater technology has enabled Petrobras to build reserves of some 16 billion barrels of oil, converting these reserves to production has proved challenging.

    Comstock to divest certain East Texas assets

    Thu, Jul 2, 2015

    Comstock Resources Inc. has entered into a definitive purchase and sale agreement with a private company to sell Comstock's oil and gas properties in and around Burleson County, Texas, for a sale price of $115 million.



    Glori Energy elects Puckett as new board chairman

    Wed, Jul 1, 2015

    Glori Energy Inc. has elected Mark Puckett as the company’s new chairman of the board. Puckett succeeds John U. Clarke, who resigned June 29 from Glori's board after four years of service to focus on other business commitments.

    EGAS to conduct largest Mediterranean seismic exploration project

    Fri, Jun 26, 2015

    Egyptian Natural Gas Holding Co. (EGAS) is set to carry out the largest seismic oil and gas exploration project in the Mediterranean, according to Reuters.

    RRC: Texas monthly oil and gas statistics

    Thu, Jun 25, 2015

    The Railroad Commission of Texas has released monthy statistics for oil and gas activity in Texas.  

    OGFJ photo of the day


    Click to view slideshow

    Oil & Gas Jobs

    Search More Job Listings >>
    Subscribe to OGFJ