Court holds that BLM violated NEPA

In its latest client advisory, law firm Burleson LLP notes that on March 31 the US District Court for the Northern District of California, San Jose Division, held that the US Bureau of Land Management (BLM) violated the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) in its environmental assessment of federal leases in California by unreasonably relying on an earlier single-well development scenario that failed to adequately consider the development impact of hydraulic fracturing when used in combination with horizontal drilling techniques.

In Center for Biological Diversity v. The Bureau of Land Management, Case No. C11-06174, Docket No. 28, 32 (N.D. Cal. Mar. 31, 2013), the court recently ruled on the parties’ cross motions for summary judgment on the issues of whether the BLM failed to comply with NEPA and the Mineral Leasing Act of 1920 concerning oil and gas leases for approximately 2,700 acres of federal land in Monterey and Fresno counties. In its Order RE Cross-Motions for Summary Judgment, the court not only held that the BLM’s assessment of federal leases violated NEPA and was erroneous as a matter of law, but also that the BLM’s finding of no significant impact based on the assessment and its resulting decision not to prepare an environmental impact statement (EIS) also were erroneous as a matter of law.

The court articulated the narrow posture before it, “the legal question of whether the BLM actions in this case were 'arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law,’” and not “the policy question of whether fracking in the Monterey Shale or anywhere else is a good thing or a bad thing.”

The court described the obligations placed on federal agencies such as the BLM. Specifically, the agency is required under NEPA to take a “hard look” at “every significant aspect of the environmental impact of a proposed action” and inform the public that it indeed has taken environmental considerations into account before taking action, which is accomplished through the preparation of a detailed environmental impact statement (EIS).

The court concluded that further environmental analysis was necessary and that it was unreasonable for the BLM not to at least consider reasonable projections of drilling in the area that include fracking operations. The BLM ultimately argued that the potential effects of fracking on the parcels at issue are largely unknown. The court agreed, noting that it was this lack of knowledge that made a proper investigation so crucial. The court held that the BLM’s dismissal of any development scenario involving fracking did not provide the “hard look” at the issue that NEPA requires.

Related Articles

Stabilis Energy to purchase Encana’s domestic LNG business

04/15/2014

Stabilis Energy has signed a definitive agreement to purchase substantially all of the US-based assets of Encana Natural Gas Inc., a subsidiary of Encana Corp.

American Energy Partners hires Launer as senior VP

04/15/2014

American Energy Partners LP has hired Curt Launer as its senior vice president of capital formation.

 

Chevron, YPF continue development of Vaca Muerta shale in Argentina

04/14/2014 Chevron Corp. confirms that subsidiaries of the company have signed agreements with the Argentine oil company YPF SA to continue development of shale oil and gas resources from the Vaca Muerta form...

Exterran Partners acquires assets from MidCon Compression

04/14/2014 Exterran Partners LP and Exterran Holdings Inc. report that Exterran Partners has completed its acquisition of compression assets from MidCon Compression LLC, a subsidiary of Chesapeake Energy Corp...

Oryx enters Permian with $300M equity commitment

04/09/2014 Oryx Midstream Services LLC has received an equity commitment totaling up to $300 million, and will pursue midstream opportunities in the Permian Basin, focusing initially on the Delaware Basin in ...

More Oil & Gas Financial Articles

Stabilis Energy to purchase Encana’s domestic LNG business

Tue, Apr 15, 2014

Stabilis Energy has signed a definitive agreement to purchase substantially all of the US-based assets of Encana Natural Gas Inc., a subsidiary of Encana Corp.

American Energy Partners hires Launer as senior VP

Tue, Apr 15, 2014

American Energy Partners LP has hired Curt Launer as its senior vice president of capital formation.

 

Chevron, YPF continue development of Vaca Muerta shale in Argentina

Mon, Apr 14, 2014

Chevron Corp. confirms that subsidiaries of the company have signed agreements with the Argentine oil company YPF SA to continue development of shale oil and gas resources from the Vaca Muerta formation located in the Neuquén province in Argentina.

Exterran Partners acquires assets from MidCon Compression

Mon, Apr 14, 2014

Exterran Partners LP and Exterran Holdings Inc. report that Exterran Partners has completed its acquisition of compression assets from MidCon Compression LLC, a subsidiary of Chesapeake Energy Corp., for approximately $360 million.

Oryx enters Permian with $300M equity commitment

Wed, Apr 9, 2014

Oryx Midstream Services LLC has received an equity commitment totaling up to $300 million, and will pursue midstream opportunities in the Permian Basin, focusing initially on the Delaware Basin in Texas and New Mexico.

Most Popular

Oil & Gas Jobs

Search More Job Listings >>
Subscribe to OGFJ